BSA Decisions Ngā whakatau a Te Mana Whanonga Kaipāho

All BSA's decisions on complaints 1990-present

All Decisions
Small and Television New Zealand Ltd - 1997-093

TV One. Live broadcast of rugby match. Rugby player injured in an off-the-ball incident and as a result of the injuries incurred, retired from the game. Complaint that there was minimal criticism from any of the commentary team of the violent and unprovoked incident. Not upheld (balance, violence).

Young and Radio New Zealand Ltd - 1997-094

National Radio. News item reported that one of a dozen escaped capuchin monkeys "had to be destroyed" because it could not be captured. Complaint about use of phrase. Not upheld (accuracy)

Harris and Television New Zealand Ltd - 1997-084

60 Minutes. Item profiled two members of a rugby team and a "bleep" was used on a number of occasions to block out some of the language used by the coach. Complaint that the offensive language had been insufficiently deleted from the broadcast. Not upheld (good taste and decency): the offensive language adequately bleeped out.

Currie and Television New Zealand Ltd - 1997-086

Tonight. News item reported concern about the growing number of accidents in both Australia and New Zealand involving drivers who had taken drugs, as distinct from those affected by alcohol. Complaint that the item was misleading. Not upheld (accuracy).

Terry and Television New Zealand Ltd - 1997-087

One Network News. Item about a nationwide campaign, including advertisements focussing on the theme of procrastination, being launched to recover millions of dollars in unpaid fines. Declined to determine (balance): complaint bordering on vexatious.

Pietersma and Television New Zealand Ltd - 1997-079

Fair Go. Item dealt with one woman's unsatisfactory experience of signing up with a fitness centre. Complaint that the programme was biased against complainant and her company and that it was inaccurate. Not upheld (fairness).

McGinley and Channel Z - 1997-080

Channel Z. Chief Executive of a company which had placed an advertisement that there wasn't a single benefit in going bald was phoned at work by an unidentified caller who wished to put forward the benefits he saw in going bald. The resulting conversation, without the CE's knowledge, was recorded, edited and then broadcast. Not upheld (fairness).