During a discussion about local government revenue and expenditure on a broadcast of The Panel, panellist Mary Lambie said Auckland Transport staff ‘need to be lined up and frankly shot because why do we spend so much on [road] cones?’ The Authority1 did not uphold two complaints that the comment, and Lambie not revoking the comment or apologising when given the opportunity, breached the offensive and disturbing content and promotion of illegal or antisocial behaviour standards. In context, the comment was flippant hyperbole made in a live discussion to express disapproval over local government spending. It was not a call to action. Intervention by the host and subsequent clarification of the comment by Lambie helped mitigate any harm caused by the broadcast. Overall, the broadcast carried high public interest given its discussion of public policy, and any harm caused did not outweigh the broadcaster’s right to freedom of expression.
Not Upheld: Offensive and Disturbing Content, Promotion of Illegal or Antisocial Behaviour