Skip to main content


Download PDF:
Assessment of Broadcasting Standards Authority Decisions (PDF 189.41 KB)

 

Date published: April 2006

Researcher/Author: Professor J F Burrows

Scope

  • Assesses the legal robustness of the decisions, the quality and the consistency of the legal reasoning in the decisions

Methodology

  • Viewing of all decisions of BSA released during 2005
  • Selected 75 for closer study

Results

  • From a legal perspective, the BSA decisions are very good
  • Exhibit appropriate level of rigour and analysis based on principles which are legally sound
  • Assessment based on: structure, language, the standards, reasoning, consistency, relationship with the law, accuracy, balance, Bill of Rights Act, orders
  • Very little objection from a legal point of view or any other point of view to the way BSA performs its statutory task
  • Impressed with the succinct yet persuasive nature of the decisions and with the consistency they display
  • Summarises in the form of brief rules the principles which the Authority applies specifically on Fairness, Balance and Privacy standards and in the section on costs
  • Where such rules have developed, one should perhaps be thinking of a way of publicising them to make them more accessible